In this week’s commentary update, readers discuss the wave of skyscrapers being built despite the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center 20 years ago and discuss other important stories.
Following the attack on the Twin Towers on September 11, 2001, which caused the collapse of the pair of 110-story skyscrapers in lower Manhattan, many people have wondered about the future of high-rise buildings. .
However, there has been an increase in the number of skyscrapers over the past 20 years.
“We thought [9/11] would put an end to ambitions to build high for a long time, ”said James von Klemperer, chairman of Kohn Pedersen Fox, who is responsible for the design of four of the world’s 10 tallest skyscrapers.
“The higher you go, the less connected you are”
Commentators are torn. “I’m not sure replacing the two towers with a new, even bigger one is a good idea,” said Englebert.
JZ also disliked the construction of tall buildings: “I am almost insulted by the reminder that the skyscraper virus continues to spread. Waste of energy, waste of resources, almost impossible to protect indefinitely . A physical reflection of the end – a capitalist, win-win approach to the economy. And all the priapic phalli to boot. “
“I never liked or wanted to live above more than four-six stories,” Kate Wright continued. “The higher you go, the more it seems there is less connection with the neighbors and the neighborhood. I also don’t like the space left at ground level – again very disconnected.”
Jacopo disagreed: “Taking care of your neighbors comes with age and personality, not with the floor number you live in. I care more about my neighbors now that I live on the 30th floor. of my building. “
What do you think of the increase in the number of skyscrapers after September 11? Join the discussion ›
Commentator calls climate research center a “masterpiece”
Readers are in awe of the footage from the Ilulissat Icefjord Center, a center for climate research and visitor reception on Greenland’s rugged coastal landscape designed by Dorte Mandrup Arkitekter.
“I have been looking forward to it for a few years!” said Anarch. “Very well ladies and gentlemen, congratulations!”
Archi agreed: “I have been waiting for this since the release of the MIR renderings. A masterpiece that fits perfectly. The details are also amazing.”
“It’s extremely impressive,” JZ concluded. “Access to the roof is questionable, but certainly exciting. No exceptions! It’s time for tourism to skyrocket in Greenland. Hopefully all those boots don’t destroy the fragile ecosystem!”
Are you impressed with the Climate Research Center? Join the discussion ›
Reader accuses Norman Foster of “remarkable double talk”
Norman Foster has sparked debate by criticizing architects who have moved away from airport design due to concerns about the environmental impact of air travel.
Gabriel Martin agreed: “Absolutely on point. It is ridiculous that people want to use their political beliefs to censor and shame real artists.”
“Remarkable double talk,” said Ralph Kent, on the other hand. “How come a tax exile whose practice works for regimes involved in state-sponsored assassinations thinks he can lecture us about morals and ethics?”
“Norm’s Saudi Airport looks like a much needed use of form, materials and structure,” Jones replied. “I bet its carbon footprint is minimal. Either way, it will only be used by a small number of extremely wealthy people, so its contribution to emissions will be almost zero.”
Do you agree with Foster? Join the discussion ›
Commentator says Vincent Van Gogh’s exhibition is “excruciatingly beautiful”
Readers are divided over an exhibition of works by Vincent Van Gogh, whose walls are covered with colorful, hand-made wallpaper designed by American artist Laura Owens.
“It’s excruciatingly beautiful and refreshing,” praised JB.
Daniel Maslin was also delighted: “There is no shortage of Van Gogh exhibitions around the world, so why not try something a little different? Otherwise, it might attract a different audience.
Bobby Dazzler was less enthusiastic, calling it “Grandma’s Aesthetics.”
What do you think of the exhibition? Join the discussion ›
Read more Dezeen reviews
Dezeen is the world’s most commented architecture and design magazine, receiving thousands of comments from its readers every month. Keep up to date with the latest discussions on our comments page.